Contio BlogPodcast

Sharon Poppell Knew Why a Client's Profits Vanished. Telling Them Directly Is How She Earns Trust.

Executive Allies co-founder Sharon Poppell on the dairy-farm lessons behind how she thinks about finance, why she took the meter off client calls, and why refusing an uncomfortable conversation is what makes trust impossible.

Team Contio

Welcome to Episode 5 of Beyond the Meeting — Contio’s podcast about what happens after the room clears, where what gets said turns into what gets done.

Sharon Poppell started her career as a financial auditor. Here’s how she describes the job. You walk into a company at the end of the year and go through all their books. You hand them a list of everything they did wrong and every entry they need to fix, sometimes moving their numbers by millions of dollars. Then you leave. Good luck. See you next year.

She got tired of the leaving part. After auditing, tax work, and time inside corporate finance, she kept noticing that big companies had a team of experts down the hall and small businesses had nobody. Executive Allies, the firm she co-founded, is her answer: corporate-level finance knowledge for small and mid-sized companies, in a relationship that doesn’t end at year-end.

Aaron and Sharon have served on a board together, so he’s watched her work up close. This conversation is about where her directness comes from, and why she thinks it’s the only real way to earn trust.

Levers at the dinner table

Sharon grew up on a dairy farm. She’ll tell you it was an idyllic childhood, with haystacks to jump off and cottonseed to play in. She’ll also tell you it was her first finance education.

In dairy, a market sets the price of milk and a market sets the price of feed. Nobody gets to decide what they charge. So the talk at her family’s dinner table was about the few levers that were available: what raising milk fat would earn, which feed contracts to lock in ahead of time, and whether to keep buying feed from other farmers or buy the land and grow it themselves. Her parents chose to grow it. “Vertical integration at its finest,” she says.

She took one lesson out of that kitchen: know which levers you control, and pull them on purpose. (She also says one of her requirements for a husband was that he have no interest in going into dairy.)

No meter on the phone call

When Sharon worked in tax, she kept hearing the same story at year-end. A client had bought a building or sold part of the business, and never called the person who did their books and their taxes. When she asked why, the answer was always the same: they didn’t want to get a bill for a phone call.

So Executive Allies runs on a subscription instead of an hourly meter. However much a client uses the firm and whatever they ask, it’s included, and they know what it costs. That gives her firm stability, and it gives clients permission to call before the big decision instead of after. Aaron puts it this way: a client paying by the hour is making six purchase decisions a month. A client on a subscription makes one, and the advisor stops being a vendor and starts being an ally.

Trust doesn’t come from being agreeable

How do you build trust with a CEO who has never worked with a CFO? For Sharon it starts with onboarding. Every client gets the same six weeks, with the client’s own team involved and her firm over-communicating the whole way. Then come the questions most owners have never thought to ask.

After that, it comes down to saying what the data shows. One client right now is paying almost everyone on staff 20 to 30 percent above market. That’s either a deliberate bet on expertise or a wage burden that could sink the company, and the owner deserves to know which. Those conversations are uncomfortable, and she has them anyway. As she puts it:

If we’re unwilling to have uncomfortable conversations, there’s an inability to build trust.

Her point isn’t that hard conversations are survivable. It’s that avoiding them is the reason a real relationship never forms.

The 1 percent problem

The toughest message she’s ever delivered was about margins. A remodeling company with a lot of heart and a lot of integrity had strong years through 2022. It started slipping in 2023, then fell off sharply, and the owners couldn’t tell why. They hadn’t been tracking margin or allocating costs to individual jobs, so they never saw their suppliers’ prices climbing faster than their own 1 percent annual increases.

Sharon told them the real number was closer to 10 to 15 percent. These owners cared deeply about their community and hated the thought of taking advantage of anyone, so it was an uncomfortable meeting. What they decided to do is in the episode, and it’s worth hearing.

Somebody who says your name

Sharon helped start Connect Her Idaho with a group of women who saw the same gap: women in business leadership often don’t have mentors, and they’re even less likely to have sponsors. Her definition of a sponsor is somebody willing to talk about you when you’re not in the room. If you don’t have a seat at the table, the next best thing is someone at the table who will say your name.

She has also seen how often talented women count themselves out. Executive Allies once posted a job for a staff accountant. The strongest applicant was, in Sharon’s words, a controller, and she had applied for the smaller role because she only wanted to work part time. Sharon hired her at her actual level.

What we cover

  • Growing the CFO you already have. The CFO Accelerator is twelve months of coaching for the finance lead at a $20 to $50 million company who’s good at the job but not yet board-ready.
  • Succession is a blueprint. Sharon works with a lot of construction companies, and she thinks about handing off a business the way a builder thinks about plans: people, processes, and relationships. New people get introduced early, so the handoff is warm instead of a clean break.
  • The 80/20 handoff. Aaron explains how the best succession planners in financial advice move a client relationship from one advisor to the next over about a year, so smoothly the client may barely notice.
  • What she wants to be remembered for. Caring for people for who they are, not only for what they bring to the company, and building a firm where her team and her clients have the flexibility to show up for their own lives.

In her words

When we asked, like, well, why didn’t you pick up the phone and call us? And the answer inevitably was, well, I didn’t want to get a bill for a phone call.

If we can relieve a burden for them that now allows them to show up for their family, their friends, for their hobbies, however they want to be spending their time, we want to make that possible for them.

Try this in your next meeting

Say the name of somebody who isn’t in the room, and say what they’re great at. That’s sponsorship.

One more thing

Near the end, Sharon brought up something Aaron hadn’t asked about. She has always wanted somewhere to keep the details about a client that aren’t numbers, like the fact that they homeschool or what the dog is called. Her comparison is the doctor’s office that asks about your kids at every visit, even though you’ve already told them.

She uses Contio for that now. Two days before the interview, her meeting debrief reminded her that a prospect had first been introduced to her firm by a banker back in 2022. She says she never would have remembered that, and bringing it up made the next conversation warmer. As Aaron put it: the details that actually make a relationship are exactly the ones nobody ever writes down.

About Sharon Poppell

Sharon Poppell is Principal Consultant and Co-Founder of Executive Allies, which provides subscription-based accounting and fractional CFO support to small and mid-sized businesses. She began her career as a financial auditor and has worked in tax and corporate finance. She grew up on her family’s dairy farm and helped found Connect Her Idaho, a community for women in business leadership.

About Beyond the Meeting

Beyond the Meeting is Contio’s podcast about how leaders actually lead, build, and get real work done. Hosted by Contio CEO Aaron Klein, who spent twelve and a half years building Riskalyze — now Nitrogen — for financial advisors before founding Contio. New episodes every three weeks.

Listen instead

Spotify → Listen on Spotify

Apple Podcasts → Visit Beyond the Meeting on Apple Podcasts

Transcript

Read the full episode transcript

Cold open

Sharon Poppell: A female will apply for a job once she feels like she has met 80 to 90% of the criteria on a job description, whereas a male counterpart will apply for that same job if he feels like he’s met 30 to 40% of the job description.

Aaron Klein: And the first instinctive answer is, “I’m not ready for that.” And I have never met a male executive to ever say those words.

Sharon Poppell: And I reviewed her resume, and I’m like, “You’re not a staff accountant. You’re like a controller.” And she’s like, “Well, I know, but I just want to work part-time, and so I didn’t really feel like I should apply for a role at that level part-time.” I’m like, “What? No, we’re absolutely going to hire you, because we need somebody of your caliber on our team.”

If we’re unwilling to have uncomfortable conversations, there’s an inability to build trust.

Aaron Klein: How about the toughest message you’ve ever had to deliver to a client? Take us into that story.

Intro

Aaron Klein: Welcome to Beyond the Meeting, the show about what happens after the room clears, where what gets said turns into what gets done.

I’m Aaron Klein. I run a company called Contio, where we’re building AI that gives people more time with each other, not less.

My guest today is Sharon Poppell. Sharon is the founder and CEO of Executive Allies, which does outsourced accounting and fractional CFO work for small and mid-sized companies.

She started out as a financial auditor, and here’s how she describes that job. You walk into a company at the end of the year, you go through all their books, you hand them a list of everything they did wrong and every entry they need to fix, sometimes moving their numbers by a lot. And then you leave. You say, “Well, good luck. See you again next year.”

Sharon got tired of the walking-away part.

She also grew up on a dairy farm, which, as it turns out, taught her more practical lessons about business than even her accounting courses did.

Stick around to the end. I’ll be back with my three takeaways.

From auditor to Executive Allies

Aaron Klein: Sharon, thanks for joining us. So you moved from being an auditor and working in operational finance into founding and building Executive Allies as CEO. Tell us a little bit about that journey.

Sharon Poppell: Well, as much fun as being an auditor was, a lot of being a financial auditor is going into other companies at the end of the year, looking through all their books, giving them a list of things that they did wrong, a list of journal entries that they need to make to their books, adjusting their overall outcome by, sometimes, millions of dollars. And really seeing that, and kind of leaving and saying, “Well, good luck. See you again next year.” And then doing the same thing again, year over year.

And in that, I just always knew. And then after subsequently working in corporate environments, there was this team of experts that you could go to in that corporate world. And so then I thought, well, there’s got to be access to that same level of knowledge for small businesses. So that was the overall genesis of Executive Allies: wanting to be a support to small businesses, seeing the scale of access to knowledge that could be had at the corporate level, and then bringing that to be available for small and mid-sized businesses.

Aaron Klein: Yeah, absolutely. You’ve always struck me as a very common-sense auditor. I say that only because we’ve served on a board together, and it was actually a surprise to me that you had worked as an auditor before. My past experience with auditors has been largely positive, but in my last company, oh boy. The day that they came and said we had to go to daily revenue recognition, I was just like… because we did monthly, and we charged people per month. I’m looking at this, and I’m like, I really don’t think my auditors like me very much, because I would sarcastically challenge them and go, “Why don’t we do minute-by-minute revenue recognition? We made a penny. We made a penny. We made a penny.” Oh, goodness.

Lessons from the dairy farm dinner table

Aaron Klein: So you grew up on a dairy farm long before you were an auditor, and you had a front-row seat to how hard it is to build a small business, the kinds of small businesses that you serve with Executive Allies, and really how financial pressure can turn numbers into emotion. What did you learn then that shaped you into the finance leader that you are today?

Sharon Poppell: Oh, well, thinking about my time growing up on a dairy, it was probably an idyllic childhood, thinking about all the spaces that you have to run around and play. We played in the cottonseed, we jumped off the haystacks. All of that was so much fun. But what I did learn is, in the ag and dairy industry in particular, there’s only so many levers that can be pulled at a given time.

In the dairy industry, you have commodities on the revenue side. So milk is driven by a commodity market, and the same thing for all of the inputs for feed and things like that. That’s all dictated by a market, not necessarily by a decision that’s made by somebody that says, “I’m going to charge this for my milk.” And so I remember conversations around the dinner table like, “Okay, we can get paid a little bit more if we can increase our milk fat.” Here’s this lever that we can pull. And then here’s forward pricing, where we can get contracts on commodities like corn and silage and different things that went into it. So, taking advantage of those and making smart decisions along the way. I felt like my parents did a great job managing that, and then also managing what they could control.

A lot of dairy farmers would have to buy all of their feed from other farmers. And so my parents took the approach of, “We’re going to buy as much land as we can to grow it ourselves.” And so, therefore, streamlining the entire process, right? Vertical integration at its finest. But I was really fortunate, because all of those conversations did happen at the dinner table, so I got a front-row seat to that. And then also the work ethic that gets instilled with any farm kid: washing out the barn at probably age seven, eight; moving hand line starting at age 10.

So the work ethic was instilled. But then also, again, going back to that concept of making knowledge accessible, they had a team of people that supported them along the way. They had a group of other dairymen that they saw do things one way; they did things a different way. And bankers along the way were really supportive, too. So it was a good environment.

And the thing that I would say made me go towards the path of accounting is, one of my criteria was for my husband to not have any interest in going into the dairy industry. So that was first and foremost. When I met my husband, I was like, “Let me see your hands.” They look barely clean. We’re good.

Aaron Klein: That’s great.

No meter on the phone call

Aaron Klein: That’s awesome. Well, I think it’s really interesting that you built Executive Allies around, call it, subscription accounting and fractional CFO support, rather than the typical hourly meter. How did you want that business model to impact your relationship with the CEOs that you serve?

Sharon Poppell: The subscription model was something that was really important to me from the beginning. One, just for stability for my company. For Executive Allies, having the cash flow stability, things like that, was really important. And then also, being in the world of public accounting, and working in tax at some point in my life as well, I remember talking to clients, and they would tell us at the end of the year, “Oh, by the way, we did X, Y, and Z,” these really big decisions, buying a building, selling a portion of their business, without contacting the most important person in their relationship: the accountant, the person that did their books and then did their taxes at the end of the year.

And when we asked, “Well, why didn’t you pick up the phone and call us?” the answer inevitably was, “Well, I didn’t want to get a bill for a phone call.” And so I knew there had to be a system to deliver service where the owner can understand that it doesn’t matter how much you leverage our service, what kind of questions you ask, it’s included. And we know how much it’s going to cost. There’s no question about it. So that was where the subscription-based accounting came from. One, a benefit to us, but also a benefit to the people that we serve. That was really important.

Aaron Klein: I think that’s so wise, because there are so many times where I have not reached out to a service provider that’s based on an hourly fee. It’s like, do I make one purchase decision every month, or do I make six purchase decisions every month? And it’s not that I don’t value that person. It’s not that I don’t think their advice is great. It’s that I’m making six purchase decisions a month. And if I had that kind of model where I was just making one, now all of a sudden, I would argue that value is going up beyond service provider and becoming really… well, I’m sure it’s why you named the business that way. I was going to say a strategic ally, but there you go.

Sharon Poppell: And that was a huge part of it. We see it with our clients. We meet with them on a regular cadence, weekly, monthly, depending on what they do. But even in those conversations, they’re able to ask those questions that come up, and they’re like, “Oh, well, I might be considering acquiring a business. What do you think?” And then we can talk through, well, let’s pull in the right people at the right time and have an awareness of what could be.

How trust gets built with a first-time CFO client

Aaron Klein: How do you build trust with CEOs or business owners who may really have never worked with a CFO before?

Sharon Poppell: It’s a good question. Building trust is something that happens from the very start. When we do our onboarding process, it’s a very hands-on process, not only with our team but with the client’s team. And so involving the right people from the beginning makes a big difference, and asking questions that, most of the time, the business owners that we work with have never even thought to ask.

So, one, we have the credibility, the expertise. We hire highly experienced people, and that establishes trust from the beginning. We have a very systematized onboarding process that’s the same for every client. So having a week-by-week, six-week onboarding, we know what to expect. We try to be over-communicative during that time, so that way they’re not wondering what it is we’re doing in the background. And then bringing up the things that they probably know they need to consider. Once the data is honed and fine-tuned, usually we see some patterns, and we can bring that to light.

And so we’re not afraid to have hard conversations. We have one client right now that we’re working with where every person on their staff is probably 20 to 30% above market rate. And so when we’re looking at margins and comparing them to other similar clients in the industry, we can bring that to light. So then, one, they can have an awareness and either leverage that to their advantage and say, “Well, we’re paying these people because they have expertise in these key areas.” Or we can have some difficult decisions with them and adjust their salaries to be paid based on the performance of the company. But right now, they have a team that’s going to drive the company into the ground because of the heavy weight of that wage burden. So we’re having those conversations, and they’re uncomfortable. But at the same time, if we’re unwilling to have uncomfortable conversations, there’s an inability to build trust.

Aaron Klein: I think there’s got to be something so powerful about being able to walk in and tell somebody something about their business that they don’t know. Because it’s their business. It’s their life’s work. It’s their focal point. And anybody who’s ever met a small business owner knows that you’re kind of living, breathing, and dying that thing every day. So to have somebody be able to walk in and give you insight into things that you probably suspected but didn’t really know, that’s probably just a huge amount of value in and of itself.

Sharon Poppell: And that’s exactly it. A lot of times it is validating that feeling that somebody had. They know something’s up with why they’re not as profitable as their competitors, and they might even have an inkling of why that is. But then we’re able to peel back the layers and reveal, “Oh, here’s actually what that looks like.” And those are great conversations.

The toughest message: the 1% problem

Aaron Klein: Yeah, for sure. How about the toughest message you’ve ever had to deliver to a client? Take us into that story.

Sharon Poppell: Wow. The toughest message probably has to do with margins. We were walking into a company that was a remodeling company, and they have a lot of heart and a lot of integrity. Over the past few years, they’ve done a couple of pricing increases. When we came in with them, it was back in 2024, and we started looking at the information that they had. We saw really strong profitability years, 2020, 2021, 2022, and then it started slipping in 2023 and then really took a nosedive in 2024 and 2025.

As we started looking at it, they couldn’t make heads or tails of why, and they hadn’t done a great job tracking margin, or even allocating costs towards the actual jobs themselves. When we started digging into the information, we found that their suppliers and vendors had all seen the inflation due to COVID and just the dollars that had come into the economy, and they had increased their prices. Well, as they didn’t have any trending of prices in those areas, they couldn’t really tell exactly what was going on. And so the half-percent, 1% increases they were doing on their pricing year over year simply weren’t enough.

So we were able to have that conversation with them and tell them, “Hey, you actually need to adjust your prices up by probably 10 to 15%.” That made them extremely uncomfortable, because of what I mentioned earlier: just really high integrity, a deep care for their community. They didn’t want to feel like they were taking advantage of their customers. But off the top, they did a 6% increase overall and then targeted increases by department after that. So these are not fun conversations to have with owners, but they’re necessary.

Connect Her Idaho: mentor vs. sponsor

Aaron Klein: Yeah, for sure. So you helped to found Connect Her. Tell us about your passion behind that and what drives that organization today.

Sharon Poppell: Connect Her Idaho is a group of women, and really the idea behind starting Connect Her Idaho… it was just a group of ladies that got together one afternoon, and we were talking about how women tend to be underserved in business, especially business leadership. And one of the things that we see commonly is a lack of mentorship, and sometimes even a lack of sponsorship. What I mean by sponsorship is somebody that’s willing to talk about you when you’re not in the room. So if you don’t have a seat at the table, the best way to get acknowledged is to have somebody in that room that’s able to speak your name and speak highly of you.

One of the first events that we hosted was an event on mentorship, pairing women in leadership roles that have been through tough things, that have seen how to be successful as a woman, especially in a male-dominated leadership area. Those conversations were really important. And then pairing mentors with mentees, and then also understanding what a sponsor is and how to go about asking somebody to be that advocate for you.

Aaron Klein: That’s really cool.

Sharon Poppell: So Connect Her is just an organization that brings women together and creates a safe space for women to ask questions of one another. And we also involve men, too, so we don’t have to leave them out of the picture. But it is a different conversation when it’s female-focused.

“I’m not ready for that” and the controller hire

Aaron Klein: Yeah, for sure. I don’t know if you’ve seen this, but there’s one thing that I think contributes to that lack of women moving forward in their careers, and I’ve tried to do my part to coach against it. There have been multiple times that I’ve seen female leaders that I’ve tried to promote, and the first instinctive answer is, “I’m not ready for that.” And I have never met a male executive to ever say those words. If you say to them, “I’m thinking that I should promote you into this role,” they go, “I am ready, and I’m going to kill it in that role.” And a lot of the great female leaders that I’ve worked with are just a little bit reticent. They’re like, “I’m not really sure if I’ve got the experience necessary to do that.” Have you seen that before?

Sharon Poppell: Yeah. There are actually statistics out there along those lines, where a female will apply for a job once she feels like she has met 80 to 90% of the criteria on a job description, whereas a male counterpart will apply for that same job if he feels like he’s met 30 to 40% of the job description. And so even coaching through that imposter syndrome… everybody is subject to imposter syndrome. That’s not unique to women. But I think women wear that a little bit more than men do. And just having the confidence to take that step forward.

One of the women on my team, actually, when we went to hire her, we had a job posted for a staff accountant, and she applied for it. And I reviewed her resume, and I’m like, “You’re not a staff accountant. You’re like a controller.” And she’s like, “Well, I know, but I just want to work part-time, and so I didn’t really feel like I should apply for a role at that level part-time.” I’m like, “What? No, we’re absolutely going to hire you, because we need somebody of your caliber on our team.” But it was shocking to me that people would be willing to take a step back. And sometimes that’s necessary in a career trajectory, but I didn’t want that to be a story for somebody on my team.

Aaron Klein: I just think it’s very interesting, because the power of what you’ve helped to create there with mentoring, a huge part of that is simply getting out of your own head and saying, “I should have the confidence to apply for that, or accept that, or move on with that.”

Probably the best hire in my career to date was somebody I hired directly out of college. Literally, she graduated on a Saturday and came to work on Monday, and she was person number four in my last company. And over time, she went from what was effectively an executive assistant role (we weren’t really that big of a company, but it was that kind of role) to chief of staff, to senior VP of operations, and today is chief operating officer of that company. It’s just been a meteoric career for her. And there were multiple times that I felt like I had to push her. Today, I think she’s realized that she has what it takes to operate at that level, and she doesn’t need people pushing her for that. But she was young; it was early in her career. I used to call her the 101st Airborne, because I could ask her to parachute into any problem, and she could fix it. And those people do not grow on trees. And if you don’t know what you bring to the table and you don’t have confidence in that, it can be really, really tough to have your actual career reflect your actual value.

Sharon Poppell: Well, congratulations to you for identifying that skill set in her. And it sounds like you have been a sponsor of her over the last few years and provided her that mentorship so she could realize her maximum potential.

Aaron Klein: Definitely tried. I have to give full credit… She had some personal things going on, some tragedy that struck personally. And so I actually tried to promote her to COO, and she said, “I cannot do that. I can’t do that right now.” And I totally understood that, and got her to take the SVP role and do that for a bit. And then my successor in that company… I probably got a ton more joy out of watching him step into the role of being her sponsor and telling our board (I still sit on the board of that company), “Hey, I’ve promoted her to COO. It’s not really a discussion. This is what we’re doing.” And I grinned pretty broadly that day.

Sharon Poppell: Oh, that’s fantastic.

Developing the finance leader you already have

Aaron Klein: So I’ve heard you talk about treating institutional knowledge and customer relationships a lot like assets on a balance sheet. Talk to me about the people side of finance. How do you evaluate finance leaders who maybe aren’t ready for the next level? How do you know if you can develop them into where they need to be, or if you’re going to have to replace them?

Sharon Poppell: That’s a great question. We work with a lot of different people in finance seats, and most of them have been with the company that they’re with for a really long time. So a lot of the companies that come to us have somebody that has been with them for a long time, and usually they’re pretty good at what they do. But likely they’ve never really had somebody give them a path of growth or mentorship in accounting in particular. They may have been mentored in different areas within the business, but very focused on that particular business. And so we provide coaching and teaching, sharing our knowledge with them, and that way they can elevate within the company.

And most recently, we rolled out what we call our CFO Accelerator program, which is for companies that are in that $20 to $50 million range. They don’t need a real high-end CFO on the team. They don’t need somebody that’s taken a company public in an IPO, anything like that. But they need stronger financial leadership than what they have. And so typically, the first inkling that they have is, “Oh, we probably should hire for that role.” Well, the person that they have currently might be a great fit for that role, but they don’t quite have the expertise of being board-ready. So we’ve developed a coaching program to take them through a full 12 months of getting them to be board-polished: developing a stronger process around month-end close, budgeting and forecasting, and all of that, giving them a roadmap to be that elevated CFO that the company needs.

Aaron Klein: That’s pretty cool. I didn’t know that about your firm. So it’s kind of like a CFO development program, really. And I love that, because it reinforces your core business. All of those CFOs are still going to need the kind of help and support and guidance that you provide.

Sharon Poppell: Well, and there are quite a few people in that role that want to grow. Their CEO doesn’t have the accounting experience to tell them what to do. There aren’t many programs out there that have specific coaching for that role. There’s a lot of leadership and executive coaching, but it’s a little bit different on the finance side.

Aaron Klein: It is.

Succession is a blueprint

Aaron Klein: When you’re advising clients on things like succession planning, I’ve heard you argue that transferring ownership is a little bit more than just stock certificates, right? It’s relationships. It’s operating judgment. It’s financial visibility. What are the telltale signs that a company has actually built real trust there, versus maybe all of the relationships being trapped inside of one person?

Sharon Poppell: Succession planning is a beast in and of itself, and we’re seeing a lot more of that come through right now. There’s a lot that goes into making sure you have a strong plan for succession. Most recently, I have been thinking about this as a blueprint. We work really heavily with construction companies. When you build a house or a building, you have a blueprint. People come in, they know what to do, they know what their role is. The electrician comes in, and they know where to put all of the outlets and the underwiring. That’s probably not the right phrase. But the people that come in, they know what to do.

And so when you build a company, you have to have that same blueprint. That’s going to look like the people that you have on the team, the processes that you’ve got in place, and then the relationships that you’ve built along the way, and the transferability of those relationships.

Now, relationships and people are near and dear to my heart, so I never want to say that’s something that’s a saleable asset. But you can build relationships and then bring other people into those relationships, and that creates a little bit more ability for that business to be sold. And so then, when the owner steps away from the business and starts walking down the path of retirement, or whatever is next for them, there’s been somebody else that’s been introduced early on into that relationship. It’s been a warmer handoff than a clean separation of “Here’s the new person, and I’m out.”

The 80/20 advisor handoff

Aaron Klein: Right. Totally. I’ve had a little bit of a front-row seat to that with my experience in the financial advisor space, because that’s an industry that is rife with those kinds of transitions. A financial advisor gets older. It’s a very, very personal relationship. It’s a very trust-based relationship. And on the one hand, you do not want to feel like you’ve been sold as a client. Like, “Oh, congratulations. Your new advisor is this person you’ve never met before. Great. I handed them all of your records.” That’s not really the look and feel that you’re looking for.

On the other hand, for both parties, for the client and for the financial advisor, you want a succession to take place. For the financial advisor, they’ve worked very hard to build a practice. They deserve to reap the benefits of having built that asset. For the client, you want to be taken care of. You don’t want to realize at the last minute that you have to go start the search again for a new financial advisor, and you’re in this interim period.

And so it’s very interesting, because the advice that you just gave is exactly what the elite succession planners in financial advice say. Find that person, and have them start attending the meetings. They usually advise a year-long process. For the first six months, the mix of talking in the meeting is 80% the old financial advisor, 20% the incoming. And then at about six months, it starts to flip and blend over, ending up at 20% the former advisor, 80% the new. And then it’s just a much simpler handoff. Pretty soon, that new one is just handling all the calls, and frankly, the client may not even notice that much.

Sharon Poppell: That’s fascinating.

The page about the client that isn’t numbers

Sharon Poppell: Early on, when we were building… in accounting, there’s a lot of information that you have to keep: dollars, what the net income is, and overall gross profit. And I always wanted there to be a spot where you could have a page about the client personally. “Okay, I know that this client has two kids. They homeschool; they’re part of the homeschool co-op. Their dog’s name is Fritz.” Just something that housed that information. Anytime I go to a doctor’s office and they want me to retell them about my kids, I’m like, man, why don’t you have a repository of information about me that I’ve already told you?

So I’m going to do a shameless plug for Contio, because we love it. It’s so incredibly helpful to help us remember those key details, to make sure that we’re not only investing in our clients’ business, but we’re investing in our clients personally. And that gives us a leverage point.

Aaron Klein: I love that. I did not see that coming, but thank you for saying that. That makes my day. It’s not like we haven’t thought about that or tried that in the past, because that was the idea behind CRM originally, right? “Oh, we’re going to have this place that we put all these things.” Unfortunately, the problem with that is that we’re all very busy. I’d say there’s a two-factor problem. We don’t always have time to go update the CRM. Also, I would note, you’re in the client meeting, and it’s a little bit awkward, as soon as they say the name of a kid, to go scribble that down in your notes. But then we also don’t have time to go dig through the CRM to try to find those notes when it’s time for the next meeting with the client. And the less we put the notes in, the less we decide to go search for them. So that’s a really interesting challenge. And I love that you’re effectively using Contio to pull all that detail forward from every conversation, turning it into that personal intelligence about the client.

Sharon Poppell: Well, and it’s not even an active role. I was meeting with a potential client two days ago, and my Contio debrief told me, “Hey, you have a client with this person that was introduced by this person.” And then it said, “But the original introduction was back in 2022, from another banker.” And I would never have remembered that. But then in the meeting, I was able to reestablish, “Oh, remember when Mr. Banker introduced us back in 2022?” And then it’s just another validation point for the potential client.

Aaron Klein: I love that. That’s so cool. Go Contio. Made my day, made my day. That’s awesome.

What she wants to be remembered for

Aaron Klein: Well, I have a standard closing question I like to ask. When all those meetings that you’re capturing in Contio are over, what’s the one value you most want your leadership to be remembered for?

Sharon Poppell: It’s definitely about people, and it has to be caring for people for who they are, not just what they can bring to the company. So when we consider the benefits that we offer to our team, the flexibility and the hybrid situation that we offer to our team: how do we serve our clients and our team in a way that we want to be served? And when I think about what I want for my business and what I want for my personal life, I think through when I want to show up for my kids, and making sure that my team has that same flexibility, and that ultimately our clients have that same flexibility. If we can relieve a burden for them that now allows them to show up for their family, their friends, for their hobbies, however they want to be spending their time, we want to make that possible for them.

Aaron Klein: Powerful. Powerful. Sharon Poppell, thanks for joining us.

Sharon Poppell: Well, thanks for having me, Aaron.

Aaron’s three takeaways

Aaron Klein: Well, I hope you liked that one. Sharon and I have served on a board together, so I’ve gotten to watch her work up close, and she is one of the most direct and thoughtful people that I know. I had three takeaways from this conversation.

The first: if you can’t see your margin, you can’t fix your pricing. And by the time you can feel it, you could be three years down the road. Sharon walked into that remodeling company that had been strong in 2020 and ’21 and ’22, and then it started slipping in ’23, and then it fell off a cliff. And they could not tell her why. They hadn’t been tracking margin and unit economics, and they weren’t allocating costs to the actual jobs. So they’d been doing these little 1% price increases year after year, and she told them the real number was closer to 10 or 15.

And now here’s the part that I like. They didn’t do 10. These are very high-integrity people. They wanted to be thoughtful about their business, their employees, their community. They certainly didn’t want to gouge anybody. So they really did look at it, and looked at the value, and they did 6% across the board. Then they went after some very targeted increases in different parts of their business where it made sense. They tried to be thoughtful about it. That’s what a real conversation looks like. Not just the easy answer; the one that they could actually live with.

Second: trust does not come just from being agreeable. I loved her line: if we’re unwilling to have uncomfortable conversations, there’s going to be a complete inability to build trust. So it’s not that hard conversations are survivable; it’s that refusing to have them is what makes trust impossible. Most advisors, whether they’re accounting advisors, financial advisors, benefits brokers, any of these people that advise people for a living, won’t tell clients directly that something’s out of line, or that their pricing is wrong, because it feels like it might cost them the relationship. And Sharon’s argument is the reverse. Avoiding that conversation doesn’t protect the relationship. It’s the reason a real relationship never forms.

And then third: there’s a difference between mentorship and sponsorship, and most of us only ever learn how to do the first one. Her definition of a sponsor, and I loved this, was somebody who’s willing to talk about you when you’re not in the room. And if you don’t have a seat at the table, the next best thing is somebody at that table who will say your name.

And one more. I’ll just be honest that I didn’t ask for it, but Sharon started talking, unprompted, about wanting somewhere to keep the things about a client that aren’t numbers: that they homeschool, what their dog is called. Her analogy was the doctor’s office. Like, why am I telling you about my kids again, when I already told you? And I’m not going to pretend I didn’t enjoy where that went. But the idea underneath it is the really interesting thing, and it’s bigger than any one piece of software or AI. The details that actually make a relationship are exactly the ones that nobody ever writes down.

The second half of the work starts now. I’ll see you next time.

See what happens when every conversation flows into the work.

Try Elite free for 21 days. Stay on the Free plan if it's not for you.

Start for free